Ninja Creami Creamy Cottage Cheese Ice Cream

Love ice cream but want something a little healthier? This cottage cheese ice cream checks all the boxes—creamy, protein-packed, and seriously delicious. It’s inspired by the internet’s new obsession: blending the magic of the Ninja Creami with the surprising creaminess of cottage cheese. The result? A dessert that feels indulgent but won’t leave you feeling guilty.

Cottage cheese might seem like an odd choice for ice cream. But trust me—it works. It has that thick, rich texture (think cheesecake vibes!), which pairs perfectly with just a hint of vanilla and sweetness. Ready to give it a try? Let’s dive in!

Quick Recipe Details

Time Commitment

• Prep: 10 minutes
• Freeze: 24 hours
• Total: Yep, you’ll need to plan ahead—24 hours and 10 minutes.

Servings

• Makes 1 pint (that’s enough for about 2–3 servings).
• Want more? Just double or triple the ingredients but freeze each batch in its own pint container for best results.

Difficulty Level

• Super simple, even if you’re a beginner.

What You’ll Need

Tools

• Ninja Creami (for that signature creamy finish).
• Mixing bowl and whisk (to combine everything).
• Freezer-safe container (the Ninja Creami pint container is ideal).

No Ninja Creami? You can use a blender or food processor to churn your frozen mixture. It might not hit the same creamy texture, but it’ll still taste great.

Ingredients (and Substitutions)

What Goes Into It:

• ¾ cup whole milk – Keeps the mixture smooth and creamy.
• 2 tablespoons instant vanilla pudding mix – Adds a velvety texture and subtle vanilla flavor.
• 2 tablespoons sugar (or your favorite sweetener) – Monk fruit or stevia work great for a low-sugar option.
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract – For a deeper flavor.
• 1 cup small-curd cottage cheese – The unexpected hero of this recipe. Rich and packed with protein.

Swaps to Try:

• Dairy-free? Sub almond milk or oat milk and use plant-based cottage cheese. Texture might change a bit, though.
• Prefer natural sweeteners? Use honey or maple syrup.

Pro tip: Always taste your mixture before freezing—adjust the sweetness to your liking.

Let’s Make It!

Step 1: Prep the Mix

1. In a bowl, whisk the milk and pudding mix until it’s completely smooth—no lumps!
2. Add the sugar and vanilla, stirring until combined.
3. Finally, fold in the cottage cheese. For extra creaminess, blend the mix in a blender before freezing.

Smooth texture fan? A quick blend will transform the mix into pure creamy goodness.

Step 2: Freeze It

1. Pour the mixture into your pint container (don’t fill it past the max line).
2. Gently tap the container on the counter to release air bubbles.
3. Pop the lid on and freeze it flat for at least 24 hours.

In a rush? Sorry—freezing is non-negotiable. The mixture needs to be rock solid for the Ninja Creami to work its magic.

Step 3: Spin It

1. Once the mixture is frozen, place the pint into the Ninja Creami. Attach the blade assembly, lock it into the machine, and hit the Ice Cream button.
2. When it’s done, check the texture. If it looks crumbly, don’t freak out. This happens!
3. Use the Re-spin function, and watch your ice cream turn creamy. You can also add a splash of milk before re-spinning for even better results.

Customize It Your Way

Here’s where you can get creative:

Flavor Ideas

• Chocolate Fix: Stir in 2 tablespoons of cocoa or chocolate protein powder.
• Berry Boost: Toss in some mashed strawberries or raspberries before freezing.
• Nutty Swirl: Add a spoonful of peanut butter or almond butter during processing.

Seasonal Flavors

• Summer? Try mango or peach puree.
• Winter? Add a dash of cinnamon or nutmeg for a warm twist.

Serving and Storing Tips

How to Serve

Serve it in chilled bowls or cones. Want to go the extra mile? Add some fun toppings like:

• Fresh fruit
• Chocolate shavings
• Crushed nuts

Leftovers?

Store your ice cream in the Ninja Creami pint container. Smooth the surface before refreezing. To enjoy it again:

1. Let it sit at room temp for 10–15 minutes.
2. Re-spin if needed to get that creamy texture back.

This recipe is proof that ice cream can be healthy, simple, and downright delicious. So grab your Ninja Creami, whip this up, and enjoy a treat that feels like a cheat—but isn’t. You’ll love it. Your taste buds will thank you. And who knows? You might just convert some cottage cheese skeptics along the way!

Print