14 Paleo Ice Cream Recipes

Ah, summer! It brings sunshine, beach days, and the irresistible call of a creamy ice cream cone. But if you’re following a Paleo diet, indulging in regular ice cream can feel like a no-go.

Fear not! After years of baking and kitchen experimentation, I’ve stumbled upon some absolutely fantastic Paleo ice cream recipes that have transformed my dessert game. I can’t wait to share these with you!

These recipes are not just dairy-free alternatives; they encapsulate all the rich, creamy goodness we love about the classic ice cream experience. As someone who has tested these recipes countless times in my quest for the perfect Paleo treat, I can confidently say that each one delivers on flavor while embracing wholesome ingredients.

In this listicle, you’ll discover a curated collection of 14 irresistible Paleo ice cream recipes that will have you scooping with joy! From classic vanilla to bold flavors like mint chocolate chip, these recipes are bound to impress. So grab your ice cream maker (or, no worries, a blender will do just fine) and let’s dive into these delicious creations!

1. Paleo Vanilla Ice Cream

First up is the Paleo Vanilla Ice Cream from Ice Cream In. There’s something to be said about classic vanilla—it’s the base for so many flavors but stands beautifully on its own. This version is creamy, yet light, with a hint of sweetness that won’t weigh you down.

What I love about this recipe is its simplicity. With just a few clean ingredients, you can whip up a delightful ice cream that tastes like a treat without the guilt. I often find myself blending in some fresh fruit for a fancy twist, and trust me, you’ll fall in love with every luscious scoop!

2. Homemade Chocolate Ice Cream with Coconut Milk

Next, let’s talk about the Homemade Chocolate Ice Cream with Coconut Milk from Ice Cream In. If you’re looking for something rich and decadent, this recipe won’t disappoint. The chocolate flavor is intense, and the creamy coconut milk base makes it dairy-free and Paleo-friendly.

I remember the first time I made this—my friends were amazed that it was a healthier version of chocolate ice cream! A little secret? Drizzling some unsweetened chocolate sauce on top takes it from great to absolutely heavenly.

It’s perfect for those days when you want a little indulgence without compromising on your goals.

3. 4-Ingredient Almond Butter Paleo Ice Cream

Introducing the charming 4-Ingredient Almond Butter Paleo Ice Cream from Ice Cream In. If you’re a fan of almond butter like I am, you’re going to be obsessed with this one. Creamy almond butter combined with a touch of sweetness creates a flavor that is both nutty and fulfilling.

The minimal ingredient list makes it super easy to whip up, and believe me, it’s hard to stop at just one bowl. Personally, I love adding some chopped dark chocolate or toasted almonds as a topping to elevate the experience. This is the kind of ice cream that feels like a little hug in a bowl!

4. Paleo Cinnamon Ice Cream

Next on the list is the delightful Paleo Cinnamon Ice Cream found at Ice Cream In. This isn’t just any ice cream—it’s a transportive experience that feels like a warm, cozy dessert during chilly evenings. The cinnamon flavor is comforting and gives this ice cream a distinct personality.

I adore how the cinnamon warms the palate and creates nostalgia with every scoop. Try it paired with some baked apples for an ultimate treat that feels indulgent yet wholesome. You might even find it becoming a seasonal favorite in your household!

5. Paleo Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

Now, let’s get refreshing with the Paleo Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream from Ice Cream In. There’s just something about the cooling sensation of mint combined with the lusciousness of chocolate chips that makes this flavor irresistible.

The mint flavor truly pops without being overpowering, and the chocolate chips add a delightful crunch. This was honestly the ice cream I made for my last movie night at home, and it was a huge hit! I suggest keeping some homemade chocolate chips on hand for even more chocolaty goodness.

6. Paleo Strawberry Ice Cream

Let’s talk about summery vibes with Paleo Strawberry Ice Cream from Ice Cream In. If you’ve got fresh strawberries on hand, this recipe is the perfect way to showcase their natural sweetness. The vibrant pink color is not just pretty; it tastes like sunshine on a warm day!

I’ve found that pureeing some fresh strawberries into the mixture creates a beautiful texture that you won’t want to miss. Sometimes I add in a splash of vanilla for extra depth, and it’s simply divine. You might just want to make it a regular staple in your freezer!

7. Paleo Pineapple Coconut Ice Cream

Next is the tropical delight known as Paleo Pineapple Coconut Ice Cream from Ice Cream In. This is summer in a bowl, folks! Combining sweet pineapple with creamy coconut creates a luscious dessert that instantly transports you to a dreamy beach.

It’s perfect for hot afternoons and pairs wonderfully with fresh fruit on the side. Plus, I love the fact that it’s so easy to make. You’ll absolutely find yourself dreaming of sunny days and breezy getaways with every delightful bite!

8. Almond Joy Vegan Paleo Ice Cream

Are you a fan of the Almond Joy candy bar? Then you have to try the Almond Joy Vegan Paleo Ice Cream from Ice Cream In. This recipe brings all those classic flavors into a creamy, dreamy ice cream experience, minus the guilt.

From the rich chocolate base to the nutty almond flavor and coconut shavings, each scoop is surprisingly satisfying. I like to sprinkle extra chocolate chips on top for an added treat—after all, who doesn’t love a little extra chocolate? It’s like indulgence turned wholesome!

9. Coconut Ice Cream

The simplicity of Coconut Ice Cream from Ice Cream In deserves a shout-out. This recipe is a dream for coconut lovers, delivering a creamy and rich texture that’s also dairy-free. The naturally sweet flavor of coconut shines through beautifully!

I often find this to be a great base to add other flavors—like a touch of lime for a refreshing citrus twist or some chocolate for a more complex taste. Whatever way you choose, this ice cream is uncomplicated yet delivers bliss in every scoop.

10. Coconut Milk Ice Cream

Next up is the wonderfully smooth Coconut Milk Ice Cream from Ice Cream In. The key to achieving that creamy texture lies in using full-fat coconut milk, which makes all the difference. This ice cream makes for a perfect canvas for any mix-ins you desire!

I often enjoy it plain because the flavor is inherently delicious. However, when I feel adventurous, I mix in pieces of dark chocolate or chopped fruit for extra fun. This recipe is perfect for spontaneous cravings—so quick to whip up, and oh-so-good!

11. Banana Ice Cream

Let’s not forget the beloved Banana Ice Cream from Ice Cream In, which is hands-down one of the simplest and most wholesome recipes you’ll ever make. Just freeze ripe bananas, blend, and voila! You have a creamy treat that’s 100% guilt-free.

I love how you can customize this base flavor by adding in cocoa powder for chocolate banana ice cream or even peanut butter for an extra indulgent experience. Seriously, it’s like magic! Plus, it’s a great way to use up those overly ripe bananas.

12. Whole30 Banana Coconut Ice Cream

For those sticking to Whole30, the Whole30 Banana Coconut Ice Cream from Ice Cream In is the perfect pick! With its coconut base and banana sweetness, this ice cream checks all the right boxes for creamy, dreamy goodness.

I appreciate that it aligns with strict Whole30 guidelines, and the flavor profile is refreshing and light, making it a suitable dessert for any occasion. You can also add some nutmeg or cinnamon for a hint of warmth, which is delicious!

13. Whole30 Strawberry Coconut Ice Cream

Next, you’ll want to scoop up the Whole30 Strawberry Coconut Ice Cream from Ice Cream In. If you love the combination of coconut and strawberries, this recipe will surprise you with its freshness and vibrant taste.

The strawberries shine through, and I often find myself relishing the balance of flavors as the creamy coconut base complements the tangy strawberries. It makes for a refreshing dessert ideal for any summer day—and trust me, it tastes even better when enjoyed outdoors!

14. Avocado Ice Cream

Lastly, we have an unexpected but delightful gem: Avocado Ice Cream from Ice Cream In. Now, I know what you might be thinking, but hear me out—avocado creates an exceptionally creamy texture that’s truly addictive!

This recipe allows the natural flavor of avocado to shine, and when sweetened correctly, it’s a surprisingly delicious treat! Adding a dash of vanilla extract brings everything together beautifully. I often find myself using ripe avocados that may have been overlooked before, which is a fantastic way to reduce waste!